Agentic Commerce: The Google vs. OpenAI Battle
By Jim Lundy
Agentic Commerce: Google and OpenAI on a Collision Course
The race to define the operating system for AI is expanding into a new, critical territory: commerce. Just two weeks after Google announced its Agent Payments Protocol (AP2) backed by a vast consortium, OpenAI has fired back, launching its own Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP) in a tight partnership with Stripe and Shopify. The two tech titans are now on a direct collision course to control the foundational rails of AI-driven transactions. This blog analyzes these competing announcements and what they signal for the future of commerce.
Why OpenAI Launched its Agentic Commerce Protocol
OpenAI’s move is a direct effort to close the loop between user queries and commercial transactions within its own ecosystem. While Google’s protocol aims to be a universal standard for all agents, OpenAI’s protocol is purpose-built to turn ChatGPT’s massive user base into a transactional powerhouse. By partnering with Stripe for payments and integrating directly with e-commerce giants like Shopify and Etsy, OpenAI is creating a powerful, vertically integrated channel. The goal is to make purchasing a product as simple as continuing a conversation, transforming ChatGPT from a research tool into a seamless point of sale. One thing is clear – online shopping, particularly for Gen Z, is changing.
Analysis
OpenAI is not standing still and is not ceding Agentic Commerce to Google. The simultaneous emergence of these two protocols signals a fundamental battle for the future of digital commerce. We are witnessing two distinct philosophies clash. Google, with its 60+ partners including major payment networks like Mastercard and enterprise players like Salesforce, is pursuing a broad, consortium-based approach. It aims to establish AP2 as the open, foundational utility for all agentic transactions, akin to an industry-wide technical standard. This is a long-term play to become the underlying plumbing for the entire ecosystem.
In contrast, OpenAI and Stripe are taking a product-led approach. They are leveraging ChatGPT’s enormous user engagement and Shopify’s merchant network to create a de facto standard through rapid adoption. Their strength is not a wide consortium but a direct and immediate path to the consumer. This sets the stage for a classic standards war: Google’s open utility versus OpenAI’s integrated product. While Google has the broader initial coalition, OpenAI has the immediate user base and a direct, compelling use case that merchants can activate today.
What Should Enterprises Do?
This is not a time to place bets on a single winner. For any enterprise involved in e-commerce, payments, or digital services, the immediate task is to monitor both protocols with extreme diligence. Retailers using Shopify have a clear path to begin experimenting with OpenAI’s ACP and should do so to gather early data on this new channel. Financial institutions and payment processors must engage with both initiatives to ensure future interoperability. The most critical action for all businesses is to begin developing a coherent “agentic presence” strategy. This means considering how your products and services will be discovered, represented, and ultimately sold by AI agents, regardless of which protocol gains dominance.
Bottom Line
The battle for the soul of agentic commerce has officially begun. Google’s AP2 and OpenAI’s ACP represent two powerful but divergent visions for how AI will handle transactions. This conflict is not just a technical skirmish; it will define the next era of digital commerce infrastructure. Enterprises cannot remain on the sidelines. The priority is to understand the implications of both protocols, experiment where possible, and build a flexible strategy that prepares your organization to transact in a future where AI agents are the new storefront.
Have a Comment on this?